Guessing the Value of your Home

May 16, 2008 | By Kelley Koehler | Filed Under Home Selling

I was cornered the other day by someone wanting me to guess how much their home was worth. I politely said that I couldn’t quote them prices without doing some research, but that I’d be happy to pull some comparable solds for them.

Oh, no, no, no, she says. I just want to know how much you think it’s worth.

Here’s the thing: I will never quote you a price without research. Because – even if we’re just chatting at a party – I’m potentially liable for that price. So if I offhand tell you that I think your home is worth maybe $350,000, and you go sell it to your neighbor for that much, who immediately resells it for the fair market value of $425k, then guess who you’re going to be very angry at?

The crazy thing is, as soon as I open my mouth and give you any kind of advice, I’m potentially creating an implied agency relationship with you, even if we have no formal agreement. And I know most reasonable people are just looking for a little conversation, understanding we’re having casual chat, but there’s the potential that someone will take my offhand comment as firm advice.

So please – if you want me to guess the value of your home, just let me do a little research for you. I’m happy to do that. Really. It’s no problem. And I’m not even going to hound you to sell it afterwards. I promise.

tags: market value, real estate, tucson

Comments

2 Responses to “Guessing the Value of your Home”

Ricardo Bueno on May 23rd, 2008 7:55 pm

It’s kinda like when I hear “what’s your rate?” I calmly shy away from that one and don’t proceed without getting more information first.
D L Langseth on May 24th, 2008 11:36 pm

You’re smart. They wouldn’t be served well with a guess. Perhaps they are looking to reinforce their uninformed opinion that their property is worth more than it really is. And if you give them a number that’s lower than reality, they can discount you and boost their own ego based upon their superior appraisal skills.

I may have answered differently and given them a wide range like between $300K and $400K, but could stick my foot in my mouth. They have to respect the fact that you are more professional than that.

Got something to say?

Checking Your Agent’s Official Record

Burnt Adobe Homes in Tucson

Subscribe in a reader

Search this Site

Other Information That Might Be Helpful

Negotiating and Real Estate (October 7, 2008)
Question from the audience: What’s your negotiating style?

Answer: Whichever way you’re most comfortable with.

I like to discuss negotiating styles with my clients before we get too far along in either the home buying or home selling process. Some folks are very aggressive, and aren’t happy with the result unless each party has [...]
Will Mortgage Rates and Home Prices Continue to Decline in Tucson? (November 2, 2009)
Question – will rates and home prices keep going down? Answer – depends on what time period you look at. Let’s start with home prices. Will they continue to go down over the next month? Most certainly. Over the next year? It’s likely. Over the next 5 years? Maybe not. Over such a long term, there’s no way to accurately predict. If you look at the average sales price for homes in Tucson over the last few years, you can see the decline. I’d argue that the drop in home prices is slowing a bit, but there are several factors in play that could make that change – the availability of financing, the levels of inventory, the economy as a whole impacting salaries and the ability to buy and sell a home.
When the Sales Price Isn’t The Market Value (October 14, 2009)
I was doing some market value research the other day for a little Central Tucson house, in a price range where home buyers wanting to use FHA financing tend to look. I had two decent comparable sales to use – but I noticed one sold to a buyer who used FHA. And that’s a huge flag that more research needs to be done in order to use that sale as an indicator of market values.